The Nature of Information -  Selections


    A human being is part of a whole, called by us the "Universe," a part limited in
    time and space. He experiences himself, his thoughts and feelings, as something
    separated from the rest - a kind of optical delusion of his consciousness. This
    delusion is a kind of prison for us, restricting us to our personal desires and to
    affection for a few persons nearest us. Our task must be to free ourselves from
    this prison by widening our circles of compassion to embrace all living creatures
    and the whole of nature in its beauty.

                                                                                          Albert Einstein

                                                        *******

    According to modern science, the universe is an entirely mass-energy system. Its
    origins, future and many of its laws and principles remain unknown, but the mass-
    energy nature of all objects and events is established overwhelmingly. We live in
    a material world. Prime among the failures of science, however, has been its
    inability to define in mass-energy terms mind, consciousness, consciousness of
    self, cognition, intentionality or volition and mental phenomena in general. The
    most it has been able to achieve is to restate the age-old mind-body problem as
    the brain-mind problem, and identify mind as a mass-energy system that
    manipulates or processes something we call information.

    But contrary to general opinion, both within and outside science, the word
    information has no definition that establishes its identity as a physical
    phenomenon valid for all its uses. Therefore, identifying ourselves as information
    processors, and mental events as information processes, lacks real meaning in
    the absence of an understanding of the true nature of information. This paper
    provides one. It defines information in wholly mass-energy terms in every sense
    in which it is or could be used, not only making possible a true unification of
    matter and mind, but revealing, in the process, the fundamental mechanism
    inherent in the mass-energy universe by which physical systems are created and
    able to organize and control their own behavior, enabling us to understand the
    universe, including mind and all mental phenomena, as an entirely mass-energy,
    material or physical system. The pathway is as follows:

    1. Information, in every sense in which it is or could be used, both within and
    outside science, will be seen to be the exact equivalent of what generally is
    known as form.

    2. Form will be redefined as a mass-energy or physical, rather than an abstract
    phenomenon.

    3. The fundamental creative and control mechanisms of the universe will be seen
    to be embodied in the use of forms as information, that all information is the
    processing of mass-energy forms.

    4. All mental events, including cognition, feelings, volition and all forms of
    consciousness, including consciousness of self, will be able to be defined as
    flows of mass-energy forms, and whatever it is we call mind will be seen as a
    wholly mass-energy, form-manipulating process.

    5. This will enable us to understand and define the universe as a mass-energy
    system that exercises its creative, control and communication functions by
    manipulating forms of itself – i.e., structures, patterns, shapes and arrangements
    or organizations of matter, many of which remain constant through inward and
    outward flows of mass-energy, allowing us to see ourselves as forms of a self-
    organizing, self-controlled, mass-energy universe. As physicist, Victor Weisskopf
    wrote, “Nature, in the form of man, begins to recognize itself. (p. 2).

                                   
              *******

    As a result of the fact that information seems always and everywhere to be the
    equivalent of form, we need to understand the precise relationship between
    information and form in order to get at the true identity of both. For instance,
    while all information processes are form processes, the reverse is not true.
    Patterns of radiation above a certain frequency destroy living tissue, and so are
    not informational to the receiver. Most chemical molecules in the body – e.g.,
    carbohydrates, hemoglobin, phospholipids, etc., are used for structure or energy
    production, and so their form is not primarily  information related, even though
    information flow is a necessary element of their activity. So, if all information is
    form, but not the exact equivalent of form, we need to know what type of form it
    is, what its unique geometric characteristics are, how information can be defined
    in mass-energy terms, and the identity of what we call knowledge, consciousness
    and mind that would result from such a definition. The pathway to this can come
    from understanding the most fundamental nature of what we call form, and being
    able to define it in entirely mass-energy terms. (p. 6).

                                   *******

    At the deepest level of our understanding of the mass-energy universe, then, we
    can see that there is a third fundamental ingredient in addition to matter and
    energy that is essential to the identity of every mass-energy event, process and
    system – its form. At the most basic level, the universe can be understood most
    generally and economically as a mass-energy-form-manipulating system. (p. 9).

    It is clear that, at every level of the known universe as characterized by modern
    science, form plays a critical role in all events, objects and processes – in the
    large-scale geometrical/field identity of the space-time continuum, the strings of
    string theories, the particle/wave systems of quantum theory, atomic electron
    patterning, the structure of chemical molecules, and the form-driven
    communication and control functions of cells, organisms, nervous systems,
    brains and minds. In order for us to understand the universe as a total mass-
    energy system, we must accept the fact that, in addition to mass and energy, it
    contains a third fundamental ingredient – an intrinsic element inherent all mass-
    energy events – the primary organizing principle of the universe – form - that
    there is a morphological or geometrical component to the universe that
    generates all its creative, communication and control processes, and plays an
    essential role in the identity and behavior of all physical events and systems. (pp.
    10-11).

                     
                          *******

    We have seen that information is, in all cases, a form phenomenon, but need to
    understand its meaning, value or significance to mass-energy systems in order to
    understand how it can come to be understood in entirely mass-energy terms as
    what we call meaningful knowledge. An example of information processing that
    can provide a pathway to this goal is contained in a description of information
    flow by W. Ross Ashby:

    “To get a picture of the amount of coding that goes on during the ordinary
    interaction between organism and environment, let us consider, in some detail,
    the comparatively simple sequence of events that occurs when a gale warning is
    broadcast. It starts as some patterned process in the nerve cells of the
    meteorologist, and then becomes a pattern of muscle movements as he writes or
    types it, thereby making a pattern of in marks on paper. From here it becomes a
    pattern of light and dark on the announcer’s retina, then a pattern of retinal
    excitation, then a pattern of nerve impulses in the optic nerve, and so on through
    his nervous system. It emerges as a pattern of lip and tongue movements, and
    then travels as a pattern of waves in the air. Reaching the microphone it
    becomes a pattern of variations of electrical potential, and then goes through
    further changes as it is amplified, modulated and broadcast. Now it is a pattern of
    waves in the ether, and next a pattern in the receiving set. Back again to the
    pattern of waves in the air, it then becomes a pattern of vibrations traversing the
    listener’s eardrums, ossicles, cochlea, and then becomes a pattern of nerve
    impulses moving up the auditory nerve. Here we can leave it noticing that this
    very brief account mentions no less than sixteen major transformations through
    all of which something has been preserved, although the superficial appearances
    have changed almost out of recognition. (p. 14)

                      
                          *******

    The interpretation of mind discussed above allows us to understand mind-body
    duality as an arbitrary compartmentalization in the characterization of what is
    actually a unitary system. The ability of drugs and other chemical substances to
    alter mental processes - consciousness, feelings, memory and cognitive
    capacity, the power of the mind to stimulate bodily changes, such as lowering
    heart and respiration rate, raising or lowering skin temperature, the capability of
    a sheer act of will to force the body to respond to danger or other stimulus,
    mental disciplines that produce enhanced performance, illness destroying
    personality and character, all are evidence of the intimate interaction between
    mind and body that can be accounted for seamlessly by understanding them as
    mass-energy form-manipulating processes. (p. 24).

                       
                         *******

    Whatever insights we gain, or advances in our thinking we make, it seems
    unarguable that, if mind can arise in any mass-energy system capable of
    processing mass-energy and form at sufficiently complex levels, we no longer
    reasonably can interpret it as some transcendent or metaphysical entity that
    enters and leaves physical systems – primarily human beings; we must accept it
    as a complex class of mass-energy, form-driven control mechanisms, and,
    critically, as evidence of our interconnectedness to all living organisms. Minds,
    wherever they exist, must be seen as legitimate forms of the universe, entitled to
    survive and potentiate their existence. This understanding will allow us to move
    toward the day when predation on other sentient forms (other minds) is
    eliminated from our ethos and actions as unacceptable, and we have learned to
    live in peace and harmony with all other forms. Only then will we have reached
    our extraordinary potential as forms of nature recognizing itself, “widened our
    circles of compassion to embrace all living creatures and the whole of nature in
    its beauty,” and taken on the moral responsibility that accompanies our
    knowledge – to be the champions of the inalienable validity of all forms of the
    universe, the only home any of us will ever know. (p. 25).


                                                 
Copyright (c) 2010 by Paul Young